Victorian Government entrenches Englobo

Places Victoria, a government agency that once competed with private land developers to limit their pricing power, is to sell all its remaining land holdings on Melbourne’s outskirts to a single buyer, the AFR reports today.

Rebecca Thistleton has Places Victoria acting chief executive Peter Seamer saying the decision to change the sale strategy was made to secure the highest possible return to the state.

What utter, utter garbage.

Selling its entire holdings in one line means only the biggest buyers with the deepest pockets can bid. Everyone else is excluded. Limiting the buyer pool in this way has two consequences.

Firstly, Victoria will get a lot less money – tens of millions less – for this valuable land than it would otherwise. Places Victoria wrote down the value of the land by $42 million in 2012. Sale on these terms means even the written-down valuation is unlikely to be met.

Secondly, selling these englobo estates to a single entity gives the buyer every incentive to withhold the land from the market with a view to driving up the price. The lucky winner also pays no State Land Tax following the dismal Napthine government decision to exempt undeveloped land in the Urban Growth Zone from this incentive to put land to its best and highest use.

On offer are three aggregations in Craigieburn, Epping and Officer totalling 680 hectares. Originally, the three sites were to be offered to 28 developers. Their competition would have maximised the return to the state and pushed the land onto the market.

So when some Suit performing his noblesse oblige in the Napthine government claims to be an astute financial manager yet an important civic amenity can’t be afforded, please remind them of this moment.

If the citizens of Victoria understood this deception and how it bogs their lives in debt, wage-taxation and conformity, our political classes would be forcibly ejected from their cosy positions. Ignorance is not bliss.


  1. Peter06-07-2013

    On the issue of maximum state gain you are of course correct, but the problem is

    1. How do you get the average Aussie to give a damn, apathy rules

    2. How can you convince the average Aussie that LVT is good for them when most can only dream about owning a home or collecting rents and living the good life

    Can we get copies of the traumatised society into all schools and get it adopted as reading, this is a generational task and a global one

  2. Karl Fitzgerald
    Karl Fitzgerald08-07-2013

    Peter – if more understand there is a third way, the closed minds may open. It will soon take people 30 years to pay off a mortgage, something that we could halve if we changed the tax system. The cost of looking the other way is mounting.

    As a fan of the Traumatised Society,have a listen/ read my recent interview with Fred Harrison

Leave a Reply


This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.