Where we failed: a telling chart
In his paper American Government Finance in the Long Run: 1790 to 1990 (Journal of Economic Perspectives, Vol 14, Number 1) John Joseph Wallis demonstrates that US government finance experienced three separate phases:-
Asset Finance Phase
- 1790 to 1842, where state-driven infrastructure and legal support for banks and companies were a priority. Development was financed from land sales, articles of incorporation and state government debt. “By the late 1830s, state debt was roughly eight times the debts of the national and local governments combined.”
Property Tax Phase
- 1842 to 1933 “was dominated by local governments and property taxation” where great investment in education, water and sewerage systems and other public utilities was undertaken. “On the eve of the Great Depression, local governments collected over half of the tax revenues collected by all governments and had incurred a debt for their investments equal to the national debt that remained from World War I.”
Income and Sales Tax Phase
- 1933 to 1990s had two parts: “a federal system of domestic economic programs (including infrastructure investment) funded by national grants and administered by state and local governments; and a national system of defense and of age security.” Income and sale taxes featured at national and state levels.
Wallis’ paper is well researched and engaging. I’d recommend a read by those who’ve come to see the federal income tax as the natural state of things – and this may very well include the writer himself. Remarkably, Wallis regards the reason for the rise of personal and corporate income taxes to have been “the most active level of government was the one with the access to the lowest cost revenue source.” With much reason and support, property tax aficionados will dispute this conclusion.
Although Wallis doesn’t regale us with the achievements of the property tax, particularly during what became known as the Progressive Era (1910 to 1920) when ‘single tax’ mayors progressed their cities to success and prosperity, Mason Gaffney does draw this history to our attention in his recommendations for a means of lifting New Orleans from the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina.
I see the income and sales tax period as one of worsening economic failure. As income and sales taxes came to replace efficient and fair charges upon property values (so well depicted in Wallis’ Figure 1 above), the US has come to witness a series of larger and larger speculative bubbles (similar to those I’ve shown for Australia) which are relentlessly delivering us into another economic depression.
“The Paradise Papers” prove once again that income tax remains largely voluntary for the super rich and, along with escalating land prices, is driving wage earners into hopeless debt and penury.
There are well-meaning academics and policy-makers who believe we may remedy income and company tax avoidance. We cannot.